In efforts to discover which topic I could discuss this week, I visited Danah Boyd's blog, Apophenia, for some inspiration. I came across a huge issue that I have been for the most part, completely unaware of. I think my ignorance is due partly to the fact that I am just now spending a lot of time researching technological privacy, identity, and safety issues, and partly because I never imagined such a topic could be an issue. A least not in America. A place in which I come to the conclusion more and more each day that we are merely under the illusion that we have a right to privacy. In her post “Real Names” Policies Are an Abuse of Power, Boyd tackles the issue of the emerging trend of social networks, like Google Plus, that calls for users to use their real identities, or else get kicked off the network. By real identities, I mean the name on a person's birth certificate. So technically you could be exactly who you say you are, only going by your nickname instead, but that is besides the point. Boyd lists a number of different people's reasons as to why they are ardently against this new regulation. From fear of being stalked to maintaining their professional images, the list makes a valid point that pseudonyms are an important aspect in protecting people on the web. The full list is included in the link above.
My point is though that all of the listed reasons are not only valid points, but also relatively common sense points. So my question is, why would a social network call for this regulation in the first place if all evidence leads to the idea that it limits a person's safety online, rather than protects it? After all, this is America. In my opinion, unless it is for legal or medical purposes, the people of this country should have the right to protect their personal identity when it comes to their private lives. People should be able to have a professional career in public, but then they also should be able to go home at the end of the day and feel they can let down their guard. This should extend to internet. In a day in which we live so much of our lives online, it only makes sense that it would extend to it.
Social networks may contend that the "real name" policy is meant to protect people rather than hurt them, but the truth is, if someone is going to try to hurt you, they are going to do it whether they have a fake name or not. It is like gun control laws, if someone is going to carry a gun for illegal purposes, they are going to do it whether they have a license or not. Putting your real identity out their is only giving the "bad guys" more ammunition.
Interesting post. Perhaps social networks think that requiring the use of "real names" will decrease the likelihood of "uncivil" discourses occurring on their websites? If so, do they have any "proof" to support this claim?
ReplyDelete