I chose to cover the article "Mozilla Chief: Government Alone Can't Solve Online Privacy" from FoxNews' website. The article discusses the growing issue of protecting people's privacy in a relatively new digital world. Because the problem is so new, and has to do with a source that is evolving and growing faster than anything we have encountered before, we are stuck in a place where no one really knows what the best solution is. It is still unclear whether the public or private sectors should be responsible for protecting people's lives online. Some argue that the government should step in and create legislation that sets boundaries and enforces standards for companies and social networks. Others feel that the private companies, rather than legislation, in the form of “Do Not Track” tools, should solve the problem. This is where the article I chose comes in.
In the article "Mitchell Baker, chairwoman of [leading internet browser company], the Mozilla Foundation," argues the claim that government "regulation would not be able to quell our privacy concerns" alone. In addition, she claims that private sector technology is the answer to solving Internet privacy issues, whether that is in addition to government or alone.
She then goes on to back this claim up by stating that basically to date there has not been any solution in the form of legislation substantial enough to make an impact, and therefore herself, as well as others in her position "don't know what legislation would look like that would be helpful." In addition she states that there is "no way the molasses-moving public sector could ever hope to keep pace with a tech powerhouse like Google." In other words, because the internet in changing on a daily basis, the painfully slow decision making government would never be able to keep legislation up to date. The only entities that could come close to doing so are the big guys that basically run the Internet.
The warrant in this article, that privacy is a vital aspect of human life and should be fought for, appeals to American's beliefs and values. In particular, it appeals to the common democratic belief that our privacy is one of the most important rights that we as Americans have. By appealing to such a widely embraced belief, Mitchell Baker is able to gather a larger audience.
Overall Mitchell Baker makes a valid argument, yet I feel that it would be much stronger if she could have come up with more concrete evidence to back up her claim. Although, I must admit that it would be very difficult to do so, considering the topic is so new, there really is not much precedent to back up either side of the argument.
Your post describes the article very well. Highlighting or putting the claims of Ms. Baker would have made the analysis much easier to see.
ReplyDeleteI believe that there is little the government could do in specifics for protecting privacy. It might be able to help on a general level but that opens us up to vague interpretations of the law and possibly inaction. That said, I would not like to see only for-profit companies protecting my privacy either.
I feel that your post does a good job in identifying the claim, evidence and warrants used.
ReplyDeleteYour post was very well written. It explained the article in a cohesive and easy to understand format. The post pointed out the claim, evidence, and warrant well. I also liked that you gave your opinion of the article and explained your reasoning.
ReplyDelete