Friday, November 11, 2011

Assisted Suicide: Legal or Not?

The article I am using is Should it be legal to assist suicide? by Harry Lesser.  I had a relatively easy time determining this article was a scholarly source because I found it through EBSCOhost and was able to limit the search to only articles that have been peer reviewed.  In addition to this, I determined the article is scholarly because it comes from the academic journal: Journal of Evaluation and Clinical Practice.  In addition, the author is a "Senior Lecturer in Philosophy" from the University of Manchester in the United Kingdom.

Overall, this article explains that assisted suicide's legality should not be determined on moral grounds, but instead should be based on people's individual cases.  It makes the point that assisted suicide cannot be deemed illegal on the moral ground that suicide itself is wrong because there is no universally agreed upon moral view.  In addition, we cannot simply say it is legal just because "suicide is always legal."  The author then goes on to list "two possible lines of argument for the legalization" of it.  The first is basically that people have the right to choose that they want to die with "dignity," and the second is that the law is there "to prevent harm but not to prevent doing good," and since assisting someone relieve pain and die with dignity is essentially helping, then it should be legal to assist suicide.  He then determines that the logical thing is to come up with a way to make assisted suicide available to those who genuinely need it by instating some form of criteria like what is in place in the Netherlands.  Lesser then goes on to list some possible criteria, such as a qualified doctor must preform it, the request for the assisted suicide must happen twice, it should be provided for only the terminally ill, and it must be reported.

From here he addresses the possible consequences, such as the legalization of "euthanasia and then to the legalization of involuntary euthanasia," as in what occurred in Nazi Germany.  He then goes on to say that this is not really something to worry about because over the 15 year time period it has been in place in the Netherlands, the "number of cases per annum [of involuntary euthanasia has been] more or less constant, rather than rising."  He then concludes by saying that the law in the UK should be altered in favor of assisted suicide on the grounds that it can help relieve suffering, rather than on moral grounds since there is a clear division of opinion. After this, he adds one last issue that must be dealt with on the road to making assisted suicide available in the UK. He states that it must be decided whether assisted suicide should be made "legal" or simply "non-prosecutable." After weighing the pros and cons of both, he determines that since non-prosecution has a better chance of succeeding politically, it is the most realistic way to go.  Overall, the article is very well reasoned through.  Lesser makes very logical points, and I feel has used these points to convey a successful rhetorical message.

http://web.ebscohost.com.lib-ezproxy.tamu.edu:2048/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?sid=3a0bddca-39a7-49bf-a00f-bb95e14e5bf4%40sessionmgr12&vid=11&hid=17  

Thursday, November 3, 2011

Censorship in China

After sitting here for a while, feeling like I am completely out of things to discuss pertaining to technology, it dawned on me that it may be interesting to look into the topic of Internet censorship in China.  We all hear about how certain terms and anything related to them are blocked, but I was personally unaware that they are not even allowed to have Facebook, Twitter, or even Youtube. Maybe I have just been living under a rock, but reading that on The New York Times' website completely shocked me.  It is pretty sad that I cannot even picture a world in which those things do not exist.  According to The New York Times website, in order to block sites like these, as well as anything else that is remotely considered threatening to the government, the Chinese government has created a "massive firewall," and even goes as far as to employing "thousands of paid commentators who pose as ordinary Web users to counter criticism of the government."  


Personally, this fact makes me question why people would ever want to move to a place that is so controlled in the information they are exposed to.  Because of the extreme censorship, citizens of China are basically blind to the rest of the world.  I am not saying that China is not culturally rich or ascetically beautiful, but I am saying that there is a problem when "Google searches of the English word 'freedom'" are blocked.  Not because it is an American word, but because of what the word itself means.  


After reading this article, it makes me feel very lucky to live in a country where information is not blocked... at least as far as we know.  This furthers my opinion that the American government should for the most part have no role in regulating the internet, but instead should only be there to enforce laws that protect our privacy and our lives online.  


Image Link 

Friday, October 28, 2011

Updating Our Privacy Laws

on the American Civil Liberties Union website, I was completely unaware of the fact that America's law concerning our privacy online was so out of date.  In fact, the law is older than most of the technology it applies to today! According to the American Civil Liberties Union, "the outdated Electronic Communications Privacy Act (ECPA) is allowing the government to engage in a shopping spree in the treasure trove of information about who you are, where you go, and what you do" through modern technologies, such as "cell phone providers, search engines, social networking sites, and other websites." In other words, because the law was created before all of these technologies existed, it does not apply to them.  Thus tons of our information that is now stored electronically can be easily accessed by the government without warrants, whereas if this same information was still in hard form, it would not be allowed to be accessed under law.

In my opinion, this is a huge problem! I completely agree with the ACLU when they demand it should be updated.  After all, just because a majority of the American People are not aware of this discrepancy, does not mean it is okay for the government to invade our privacy.  In a world where more and more of our information is being converted into electronic form every day, laws concerning that technology must be up to date.   As those whose privacy is being violated, we must not settle for ignorance.  Below are listed the list of changes that the ACLU feels should be made to the completely out of date law.


"Robustly Protect All Personal Electronic Information. Current loopholes in our privacy laws must be closed to ensure that electronic information, including most transactional communications, receives full warrant protection regardless of their age or nature.
Safeguard Location Information. Location as transmitted by my cell phone is clearly personal information. Government officials should have to obtain a warrant based on probable cause before accessing it.
Institute Appropriate Oversight and Reporting Requirements. Existing reporting requirements for wiretap orders must be extended to all types of law enforcement surveillance requests.
Require a Suppression Remedy. The same rules should apply for electronic and non-electronic information; if it's illegally obtained it should not be used against an individual in court. 
Craft Reasonable Exceptions. Records should only be viewed in a true emergency with informed consent and proper notice."

Thursday, October 20, 2011

The Government, or Not the Government? That is the Question.


I chose to cover the article "Mozilla Chief: Government Alone Can't Solve Online Privacy" from FoxNews' website.  The article discusses the growing issue of protecting people's privacy in a relatively new digital world.  Because the problem is so new, and has to do with a source that is evolving and growing faster than anything we have encountered before, we are stuck in a place where no one really knows what the best solution is.  It is still unclear whether the public or private sectors should be responsible for protecting people's lives online.  Some argue that the government should step in and create legislation that sets boundaries and enforces standards for companies and social networks.  Others feel that the private companies, rather than legislation, in the form of “Do Not Track” tools, should solve the problem.  This is where the article I chose comes in.

In the article "Mitchell Baker, chairwoman of [leading internet browser company], the Mozilla Foundation," argues the claim that government "regulation would not be able to quell our privacy concerns" alone.  In addition, she claims that private sector technology is the answer to solving Internet privacy issues, whether that is in addition to government or alone. 

She then goes on to back this claim up by stating that basically to date there has not been any solution in the form of legislation substantial enough to make an impact, and therefore herself, as well as others in her position "don't know what legislation would look like that would be helpful." In addition she states that there is "no way the molasses-moving public sector could ever hope to keep pace with a tech powerhouse like Google." In other words, because the internet in changing on a daily basis, the painfully slow decision making government would never be able to keep legislation up to date.  The only entities that could come close to doing so are the big guys that basically run the Internet.  

The warrant in this article, that privacy is a vital aspect of human life and should be fought for, appeals to American's beliefs and values.  In particular, it appeals to the common democratic belief that our privacy is one of the most important rights that we as Americans have.  By appealing to such a widely embraced belief, Mitchell Baker is able to gather a larger audience.

Overall Mitchell Baker makes a valid argument, yet I feel that it would be much stronger if she could have come up with more concrete evidence to back up her claim.  Although, I must admit that it would be very difficult to do so, considering the topic is so new, there really is not much precedent to back up either side of the argument.

Friday, October 14, 2011

The "Real Name" Policy and What it Could Mean for Us

In efforts to discover which topic I could discuss this week, I visited Danah Boyd's blog,  Apophenia, for some inspiration.  I came across a huge issue that I have been for the most part, completely unaware of.  I think my ignorance is due partly to the fact that I am just now spending a lot of time researching technological privacy, identity, and safety issues, and partly because I never imagined such a topic could be an issue.  A least not in America. A place in which I come to the conclusion more and more each day that we are merely under the illusion that we have a right to privacy.  In her post “Real Names” Policies Are an Abuse of Power, Boyd tackles the issue of the emerging trend of social networks, like Google Plus, that calls for users to use their real identities, or else get kicked off the network.  By real identities, I mean the name on a person's birth certificate.  So technically you could be exactly who you say you are, only going by your nickname instead, but that is besides the point.   Boyd lists a number of different people's reasons as to why they are ardently against this new regulation.  From fear of being stalked to maintaining their professional images, the list makes a valid point that pseudonyms are an important aspect in protecting people on the web.  The full list is included in the link above.  

My point is though that all of the listed reasons are not only valid points, but also relatively common sense points.  So my question is, why would a social network call for this regulation in the first place if all evidence leads to the idea that it limits a person's safety online, rather than protects it? After all, this is America.  In my opinion, unless it is for legal or medical purposes, the people of this country should have the right to protect their personal identity when it comes to their private lives.  People should be able to have a professional career in public, but then they also should be able to go home at the end of the day and feel they can let down their guard.  This should extend to internet.  In a day in which we live so much of our lives online, it only makes sense that it would extend to it.  

Social networks may contend that the "real name" policy is meant to protect people rather than hurt them, but the truth is, if someone is going to try to hurt you, they are going to do it whether they have a fake name or not.  It is like gun control laws, if someone is going to carry a gun for illegal purposes, they are going to do it whether they have a license or not.  Putting your real identity out their is only giving the "bad guys" more ammunition.    

Danah Boyd says it best when she states that these "policies aren’t empowering; they’re an authoritarian assertion of power over vulnerable people." And the truth is, this policy only adds to people's vulnerability.  Hopefully it will only be a passing fad, a technique that fails to work for Google Plus, and therefore is disregarded.  But who knows, if enough people do not speak out against it, it could become something very common.  It is our job to protect ourselves and our privacy by denying this as even an option.

Friday, October 7, 2011

Breaking Downs Arguments to Stop Cyberbullying

For this weeks post, I have come up with two different blogs that address the ever-important issue of cyber bulling.  Entering into this semester, I had little clue as to how large of a problem online bulling actually is, and then on top of that, even less of a clue as to how many people are already aware of this and who make it their lives to put an end to it.  The authors of the two blogs I will be analyzing today make their jobs just that.   This is quite evident in the rhetorical devices they use in order to establish their positions on the topic, as well as argue for what they feel is the right way to help stop it. 

            To begin with, Danah Boyd’s blog post “The Unintended Consequences of CyberbullingRhetoric” addresses how inefficient the rhetoric aimed at convincing children to cease this relatively new form of bullying is.  She argues that the current practice of lumping cyberbulling in with other forms of bulling is a mistake because often “many teens do not – and, for good reasons, cannot – identify a lot of what they experience as bullying.”  She goes on to suggest that an effective solution may be “focusing more on positive frames that use the language of youth rather than focusing on the negative.”  In order to bolster her argument Boyd uses several different rhetorical devices.  For one, she uses the method of an individual anecdote about Jamey Rodemeyer, a victim of suicide due to cyber bulling.  In the process, she creates pathos by means of calling on the audiences emotions of sorrow and empathy.  The anecdote puts a real spin on her topic, thus creating a tone of urgency and import.  In addition to this, Boyd create ethos for herself by explaining that she is learned on the top, having “spent the last seven years talking to youth about bullying and drama.” Additionally, she points out that she has written and academic draft called “The Drama! Teen Conflict, Gossip, and Bullying in Networked Publics.”

            Conversely, the other blog I chose for this week is not written by one person, but an entire, Cyberbulling Research Center, established to put an end to the problem.  Unlike Danah Boyd, the research center approaches the topic from a “we need to empower law enforcement officers!” standpoint.  They argue that in addition to educating parents and educational institutions, school-based officers need to be because they play a vital role in kids lives, by being “mentors, educators, investigators, first responders.”   They make the point that in a lot of circumstances citizens look to the law in order to shield them from harm, yet when it comes to online bullying, law enforcement officers bump into walls, being unfamiliar with “technology or ambiguity in [current] laws not designed to address such behaviors.”
In order to make this argument effective, the center includes statistics, thereby building their logos.  They claimed that of the 1000 officers surveyed over the past year “over 85% of the officers… said that cyberbullying was a serious concern that warrants the response of law enforcement. [In addition] almost 90% of the school resource officers had dealt with a cyberbullying case “sometimes” or “often.’” Like the individual anecdote in Boyd’s blog, this appeal causes the audience to see the extreme importance of the matter.  Because people usually trust police officers, the fact that the statistics are from them, only strengthens the centers claim.  They then go on to include more statistical evidence twenty five to forty percent “didn’t know if their state had a law specific to cyberbullying,” thus not allowing them to really make an impact. 
In addition, the article’s language works to generate pathos, by way of making adults feel empowered in the fight. For example, by stressing that their goal is to stop cyberbulling, and that “the more [they] accept that as [their] underlying mission, the easier it will become to see what needs to be done.”  The diction of “mission” in this quote encourages adults to feel like agents alongside police officers, thus empowering them to join the fight against cyberbulling.
Both of these blogs in my opinion are very successful through use of the three appeals in relaying their messages, as well as persuading their audiences to feel as passionately about it as them.  Personally, the most successful appeal in both of these was the authors’ use of pathos, whether it was through language or personal touches. 

Thursday, September 29, 2011

The Government: A Protector or Spy?

     With all the talk of the lack of privacy we as natives of the Internet have online, I thought it would be interesting to discuss the topic of what we feel the government’s role in our online lives should be. 
      I am sure we have come to realize by now that there is very little legislation out there protecting our online identities, at least in contrast to the vast amounts of legislation in place, aimed at protecting our physical person.   The question is though, will government enforced laws help or hurt us online? 
     I know personally, that my first thought was that we do need them.  I do not want to be the victim of fraud or any other kind of online predator, and my instinct is to just hand it over to the government and let them protect me.  But after coming across a blog by Neal Leavitt on imediaconnection.com, I began to rethink my stance.  He makes a very valid point:  In essence, more government regulation of the Internet means less freedom for its users.  It is important to point out that it also could mean even more of a loss of our personal privacy, this time by the government. 
     He then goes on to point out that it would be smarter “to get people educated and involved in their own privacy protection,” instead of calling in a third party to do it for us.  I have got to say, after reading his list of ways in which we can do this already I too feel that we do not really need more government involvement online.  If anything, we may need at least one law requiring businesses to state their privacy policies outright instead of forcing their consumers to decode the long technical jargon that they are made up of currently.  Other than that, I believe it is truly up to the individual to number one, be smart, and number two, take advantage of the resources that are out there. 

Here are a few of the ways Neal Leavitt suggests we can protect ourselves on our own that really stood out to me:

·  Do not reveal personal information inadvertently
·  Keep a clean email address
·  Realize you might be monitored at work, avoid sending highly personal email to mailing lists, and keep sensitive files on your home computer
·  Beware of sites offering some sort of reward or price in exchange for your contact information or other personal details
·  Do not reply to spammers for any reason
·  Examine privacy policies and seals
·  Remember that you decide what information about yourself to reveal, when, why and to whom

     Also something I learned from his blog is that most Internet browsers already “allow users to control online tracking,” by means a simple button.  All we have to do is go to the main page of our Internet browser, find a link to “privacy settings” and adjust it to prevent sites from following our activity so that they can post targeted adds.

     Now I am curious, what is your opinion on whether the government should become involved or not?