Friday, October 7, 2011

Breaking Downs Arguments to Stop Cyberbullying

For this weeks post, I have come up with two different blogs that address the ever-important issue of cyber bulling.  Entering into this semester, I had little clue as to how large of a problem online bulling actually is, and then on top of that, even less of a clue as to how many people are already aware of this and who make it their lives to put an end to it.  The authors of the two blogs I will be analyzing today make their jobs just that.   This is quite evident in the rhetorical devices they use in order to establish their positions on the topic, as well as argue for what they feel is the right way to help stop it. 

            To begin with, Danah Boyd’s blog post “The Unintended Consequences of CyberbullingRhetoric” addresses how inefficient the rhetoric aimed at convincing children to cease this relatively new form of bullying is.  She argues that the current practice of lumping cyberbulling in with other forms of bulling is a mistake because often “many teens do not – and, for good reasons, cannot – identify a lot of what they experience as bullying.”  She goes on to suggest that an effective solution may be “focusing more on positive frames that use the language of youth rather than focusing on the negative.”  In order to bolster her argument Boyd uses several different rhetorical devices.  For one, she uses the method of an individual anecdote about Jamey Rodemeyer, a victim of suicide due to cyber bulling.  In the process, she creates pathos by means of calling on the audiences emotions of sorrow and empathy.  The anecdote puts a real spin on her topic, thus creating a tone of urgency and import.  In addition to this, Boyd create ethos for herself by explaining that she is learned on the top, having “spent the last seven years talking to youth about bullying and drama.” Additionally, she points out that she has written and academic draft called “The Drama! Teen Conflict, Gossip, and Bullying in Networked Publics.”

            Conversely, the other blog I chose for this week is not written by one person, but an entire, Cyberbulling Research Center, established to put an end to the problem.  Unlike Danah Boyd, the research center approaches the topic from a “we need to empower law enforcement officers!” standpoint.  They argue that in addition to educating parents and educational institutions, school-based officers need to be because they play a vital role in kids lives, by being “mentors, educators, investigators, first responders.”   They make the point that in a lot of circumstances citizens look to the law in order to shield them from harm, yet when it comes to online bullying, law enforcement officers bump into walls, being unfamiliar with “technology or ambiguity in [current] laws not designed to address such behaviors.”
In order to make this argument effective, the center includes statistics, thereby building their logos.  They claimed that of the 1000 officers surveyed over the past year “over 85% of the officers… said that cyberbullying was a serious concern that warrants the response of law enforcement. [In addition] almost 90% of the school resource officers had dealt with a cyberbullying case “sometimes” or “often.’” Like the individual anecdote in Boyd’s blog, this appeal causes the audience to see the extreme importance of the matter.  Because people usually trust police officers, the fact that the statistics are from them, only strengthens the centers claim.  They then go on to include more statistical evidence twenty five to forty percent “didn’t know if their state had a law specific to cyberbullying,” thus not allowing them to really make an impact. 
In addition, the article’s language works to generate pathos, by way of making adults feel empowered in the fight. For example, by stressing that their goal is to stop cyberbulling, and that “the more [they] accept that as [their] underlying mission, the easier it will become to see what needs to be done.”  The diction of “mission” in this quote encourages adults to feel like agents alongside police officers, thus empowering them to join the fight against cyberbulling.
Both of these blogs in my opinion are very successful through use of the three appeals in relaying their messages, as well as persuading their audiences to feel as passionately about it as them.  Personally, the most successful appeal in both of these was the authors’ use of pathos, whether it was through language or personal touches. 

3 comments:

  1. You did a good job formatting your arguments about each post, beginning with a brief summary of the article's main point and then providing rhetorical evidence. One issue is that you twice misappropriated the term "ethos". Ethos only refers to appealing to the author's credibility. The first time I saw it used incorrectly was when you were talking about statistics provided by the Cyberbullying Research Center (which would be considered logos). Then in you second to last paragraph, you should have used pathos to talk about generating a feeling of empowerment. Those are small mistakes, but they could cost you big in later analyses.

    As a whole, I felt that your piece read very fluidly and transitioned well from one point to another. Very nicely done.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you for pointing those mistakes out to me! I was mistaken when I referenced the author's use of statistics. As for the other two, I think I got lazy while typing and mixed up the two words. I corrected all of them :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I to wrote about Danna Boyds blog post and like how you pointed out the use of pathos in her article. I like the way you compared the two posts and pointed out the different points they were trying to make.

    ReplyDelete