The article I am using is Should it be legal to assist suicide? by Harry Lesser. I had a relatively easy time determining this article was a scholarly source because I found it through EBSCOhost and was able to limit the search to only articles that have been peer reviewed. In addition to this, I determined the article is scholarly because it comes from the academic journal: Journal of Evaluation and Clinical Practice. In addition, the author is a "Senior Lecturer in Philosophy" from the University of Manchester in the United Kingdom.
Overall, this article explains that assisted suicide's legality should not be determined on moral grounds, but instead should be based on people's individual cases. It makes the point that assisted suicide cannot be deemed illegal on the moral ground that suicide itself is wrong because there is no universally agreed upon moral view. In addition, we cannot simply say it is legal just because "suicide is always legal." The author then goes on to list "two possible lines of argument for the legalization" of it. The first is basically that people have the right to choose that they want to die with "dignity," and the second is that the law is there "to prevent harm but not to prevent doing good," and since assisting someone relieve pain and die with dignity is essentially helping, then it should be legal to assist suicide. He then determines that the logical thing is to come up with a way to make assisted suicide available to those who genuinely need it by instating some form of criteria like what is in place in the Netherlands. Lesser then goes on to list some possible criteria, such as a qualified doctor must preform it, the request for the assisted suicide must happen twice, it should be provided for only the terminally ill, and it must be reported.
From here he addresses the possible consequences, such as the legalization of "euthanasia and then to the legalization of involuntary euthanasia," as in what occurred in Nazi Germany. He then goes on to say that this is not really something to worry about because over the 15 year time period it has been in place in the Netherlands, the "number of cases per annum [of involuntary euthanasia has been] more or less constant, rather than rising." He then concludes by saying that the law in the UK should be altered in favor of assisted suicide on the grounds that it can help relieve suffering, rather than on moral grounds since there is a clear division of opinion. After this, he adds one last issue that must be dealt with on the road to making assisted suicide available in the UK. He states that it must be decided whether assisted suicide should be made "legal" or simply "non-prosecutable." After weighing the pros and cons of both, he determines that since non-prosecution has a better chance of succeeding politically, it is the most realistic way to go. Overall, the article is very well reasoned through. Lesser makes very logical points, and I feel has used these points to convey a successful rhetorical message.
http://web.ebscohost.com.lib-ezproxy.tamu.edu:2048/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?sid=3a0bddca-39a7-49bf-a00f-bb95e14e5bf4%40sessionmgr12&vid=11&hid=17
This article certainly appears to be scholarly.
ReplyDeleteI thought your assessment of the article was well thought out, and it does appear to be scholarly. Your summary was also very thorough and informative. I honestly feel that assisted suicide should not be legalized. Instead of "relieve suffering" through assisting with suicide, why not just get the person help? Sounds like a very controversial subject.
ReplyDeleteI like your analysis on how you came across the article being scholarly
ReplyDelete